The world according to me. To sum up the general idea of the place: if History and Theory don't agree, it's not History that's wrong.
Translate
Wednesday, 24 March 2010
Ann Coulter and the Art of outraging people for fun and profit.
So Ann Coulter was supposed to speak last night at Ottawa U. So what? Ann says stuff that even I think goes too far, but much of her delivery may be for rhetorical effect. She is a narrow-minded religious type, and as such I don't want her running things any more than I want the Green Party to run Canada. I'm closer to Coulter's end of the spectrum, but closer isn't collocated. Having said that, even if Noam Chomsky and Naomi Klein were headlining something at my alma mater I'd just stay away; people who aren't threatening you (and I don't mean your ideas, I mean your precious skin) don't require violent protests, sit-ins and intimidation.
It makes these leftist Brown Shirts feel big to hector speakers they don't like out of the country, and for all of their ability to grab hold of the media they don't grasp the secondary effects of giving the Ann Coulters, David Irvings and Geert Wilders' of the world that kind of exposure. I must hasten to add that I only include Mr. Wilders in with the other two for his effect on cringing leftists; the West needs more people like him and I can't necessarily say that about Coulter and Irving as there are a fair number of them already.
OTTAWA - Hundreds of screaming students succeeded in what few thought possible Tuesday night - they silenced incendiary right-winger Ann Coulter.
Mm, not quite silenced; she got MASSIVELY more mainstream media coverage due to the screaming mob and the threatening (with legal prosecution) email generated in reaction to her mere presence than she would have had the local intelligencia ignored her. I also note that the CBC used the worst available photos of her; she's a good-looking woman and you don't get goofy shots of her without trying to. That (and the tone of the articles to a less-subtle extent) is subtle manipulation of the media, albeit BY the media. If 100 or so people who haven't been brainwashed by the relentless PC Marxism of our University system want to come and bask in her conservative glow, will that undermine all of our human rights?
The system is good at stamping out little PC clones that possess the illusion of independent thought, so not that many university students would show up for her anyway. Back in the day I probably would have (if I wasn't going out clubbing that night at least) but mostly because it baits these PC twits and I like to spar with them. I remember going to see Gwynne Dyer during Gulf War 1 with some leftish friends who obviously had never actually read what he had to say about war. They just assumed that a critic of the military must be against it. That is a product of the bullshit "Critical Theory" that likes to tear down everything that made the soft squishy society that these people inhabit possible. Western Civilization is the font from whence comes both the technology which makes 6B+ people on this planet possible AND the self-hating philosophy that stifles the free expression of ideas and has the potential to pull the whole thing down.
I confess to some ignorance (no excuse, I know) about the precise laws in Canada about expression, but I do know that we have no equivalent of the First Amendment. I cannot say "Let's kill all of the _" and expect to get away with it, so I won't. I would be interested to see the legal reaction in Canada to someone saying "Muhammad was a pedophile", evidence being him consummating his marriage to Aisha when she was nine (9) years old. I'll make an observation/prediction though: if it were libel it'd go to a real court, not some PC kangaroo version thereof.
Saying "Not all Muslims are terrorists, but all terrorists are Muslims" is not strictly accurate, but not so far off the mark as to be "ridiculous" rather than merely "outrageous". The (Muslim) girl at Western who challenged Coulter on her proposition that Muslims should take "flying carpets" so that they wouldn't blow up our airliners handled it with some class, merely leaving after being offered the option of a camel when she mentioned she didn't have a flying carpet. Coulter scored some cheap points with her base, but did nothing to use her provocative premise as an entrée to a serious discussion of the source of all of these attacks. That marks Coulter to me as a lightweight, and suggests that the dumb-ass things that she says are likely what she actually thinks.
As for the "flying carpet" comment itself, it has potential. Make an opening by pissing people off with that, then riposte their frothing outrage with something along the lines of: Muslims wouldn't even have planes if it wasn't for Christians, or at very least Western Civilization. It therefore follows that camels certainly are an appropriate transport alternative for a group who SHOULD be preferentially profiled on the basis of their religion due to their demonstrated inclination to try to blow up things that they couldn't come up with themselves. There are enough bad apples in that particular barrel to taint the bunch; Islam DICTATES that non-believers should be subjugated (when not forcibly converted or killed), so ipso facto all Muslims are a potential threat to all non-Muslims (insert relevant verse etc. of Koran here for full effect).
That, Ann, is how it's done, and I'm not even all that clever so it can be and has been done even better. It's easy to outmanoeuvre the dogmatic of any stripe, especially the ideologues, and all that it requires is a) you get them riled up first, and b) that you can back up your wacky pronouncements with FACTS, not cheap jokes to the mouth breathers in your peanut gallery. You're good at a) and it's not too late to work on b) as long as you're flexible enough to separate the "mostly-true" from the factually unassailable and recombine them for maximum rhetorical impact. You've got a pretty good gig already though , so what could I know?
Monday, 22 March 2010
Acts of War on Terror
A contributing factor to this post was a show ("Silent Warriors") that I saw part of yesterday. It involved an AK-47 attack which killed two CIA agents in traffic in Langley in 1993. The perp was a Pakistani who shot the agents, but spared the wife of one of them who was in the car. The guy was eventually run to ground in Pakistan in '97, and executed in 2002. The agents got their stars on the wall at Langley, and the widow got payback on the man who spared her life. Hmm, doesn't sound very good like that, but still technically correct.
So what, you ask? Standard disgruntled-Muslim attack, albeit before it was really fashionable, but I found that I could identify with the attacker's method, if not his motive. First, he used a gun, not a bomb, and he did it in public in daylight. He shot the men he was after, and no one else. No car bomb in the market, suicide vest on the train, he had a military target and he hit that and only that. Say whatever you want about who's side they're on (and who really knows with the CIA anyway?), but a CIA agent is as legitimate a target for upset foreigners as you can get. Ditto the suicide attack a couple of months ago in Afghanistan that killed the CIA drone crew. The bomber hit a military target, and got it because of his determination and slack security on the post.
I am not of course advocating open season on the CIA. I am merely pointing out that enemy action against military/intelligence targets is exactly that, enemy action, NOT a terror attack. 9/11, 7/7 and Madrid were terror attacks; the attack on the USS Cole and the truck bomb that hit the US Marines' barracks in Beirut in 1982 were not. Do you hunt the planners down and kill them with extreme prejudice? Most certainly, as you can't make them think that their human cruise missiles are the only ones who will pay for hurting us. In this case at least I would make sure to execute them quickly and cleanly; that's MY "due process" for our mortal enemies.
Tarring everything that's done to attack us as a "terror" attack is stupid and plays into the opposition's hands by paralyzing us. Most terror attacks are headed off by Int and law enforcement agencies, and most of the rest are so incompetently executed (I'm looking at you, Abdulmutallab) that they are almost funny. In fact they are funny, to me, when the only ones they hurt are the shitheads who think it's a good idea to kill Westerners just for being in the wrong place at the wrong time. Burning to death or losing your 'nads (you again, Umar) sounds about right to me, as I lack confidence in a Hereafter that will give these clowns their proper reward.
It does us no credit to spew panicky "terror" crap every time someone gets the drop on us. There must be a tit for their tat, but (the disproportionate "tat" I'd prefer aside) some professionalism is called for from the talking heads. I'd like to see stuff along the lines of "Yes, we lost some good people, but rest assured that the planners won't get away with it." Of course Dubya said that about Bin Laden nine years ago and we don't have his head in a box on the steps of the US Embassy in Pakistan yet. Oh well; the reward is still up, $US 27M I think, so if he's alive (which I personally doubt on the balance of evidence) it could still happen. Hell, the head-in-a-box scenario still works if he's dead...
Saturday, 20 March 2010
Whack-a-Muj in Afghanistan
The plan was to suck ISAF in and cause massive (by current standards) allied casualties in a nest of IEDs and ambush positions that the opposition had several months' warning to construct and refine. Reports I read had it that Taliban leadership was annoyed with their guys failing to die for Allah and Mullah Omar, and I can easily believe that.
That's the good news. I used the whack-a-mole analogy in the post title, but hitting an insurgent force this way (e.g. not cordoning off the area and killing anyone with or near a weapon) is more like hitting water with a hammer. If it's not destroyed (ok, it's hard to destroy water in any permanent way, but you know what I mean) it simply flows elsewhere. In any event, these two quotes tell you everything you need to know about Afghanistan:
Helmand Gov. Gulab Mangal acknowledges that the Taliban have outright control of three of the province's 13 districts. In most other districts, the only areas where the government has control are the district capitals, according to residents and some government officials.
Mangal's appointee as chief of Baghran district, Abdul Razik, hasn't been able to take up the job because the Taliban won't let him enter the area. Instead, he works out of an office in Lashkar Gah, telephoning elders in Baghran to try to persuade them to switch sides.
"How can I go there by myself if they are in control?" Razik asked. "We don't have enough soldiers or police to go with me. I can't go alone."
and:
"As long as we have 10,000 folks on the ground and open the spigot of greenbacks the success will continue," he said. "The U.S.-NATO-Karzai team will also get a boost from the large part of the media ... who will take a transitory local success and extrapolate it into a nationwide, permanent turning of the tide. How many times did we see that in Vietnam and in Iraq? How many times did the Soviets trumpet the same kind of victory in Afghanistan?"
Those who will not learn from history will keep attempting to splash around in the nation-building morass of Afghanistan. My equally dire prognosis for the democracy transplant in Iraq have not (yet) come to pass, but Iraq is a VERY different country than Afghanistan. That was merely a bad idea and unlikely to work, Afghanistan is quite possibly permanently broken.Gen. McChrystal has not proven me wrong here in the big picture. The low quality of the human material he was up against is the only thing that has kept this from being another Fallujah, but the Taliban don't have to be brave and willing to martyr themselves to control the place in the long run. As they said, NATO has the watches, but the Taliban have the time.
Tuesday, 9 March 2010
Marching with Morons
What triggered me writing about this was an article in the Times Higher Education online about attempts to open up "elite" universities to the average Nigel:
'The issue at stake is a familiar one: the make-up of the student
population does not reflect that of the UK as a whole. People from some
groups - most notably poorer backgrounds - are significantly
under-represented in the university system.
According to a 2008 National Audit Office (NAO) report, Widening
Participation in Higher Education, half the population of England is
made up of people from lower socio-economic groups, yet among the young
full-time student population the proportion is less than a third (29 per
cent). Those from better-off backgrounds are more than twice as likely
to go to university as those from the less privileged sections of
society.
But getting to university is only the first part of the equation: the
second is the type of university these students attend. Poorer students
are more likely to study at "lower status", less selective institutions,
and this affects their life chances. The divide is widest in "elite"
universities, particularly Oxbridge - a high-profile issue regularly in
the public eye. It is here that widening participation collides with
"fair access".'
Granted, this doesn't have a lot to do with the book I mentioned above, but there is a bit of stupidity involved. This cannot be any sort of surprise; the definition of the word "elite" would do for starters. The article then goes on to burnish its' brilliance with something about how it actually matters which University you graduate from. To take a couple of domestic examples, the degree from Queens' carries a bit more weight in the marketplace than one from, say, Lakehead, all things being equal. This is not to slag Lakehead or to say that Queens' is the bees'-knees, but some are more prestigious than others. "Better" is a more complex idea requiring quantifiable direct comparisons, but prestige although nebulous is easier to get a feel for.
Where this comes back on track is with the effect of successfully integrating Joe and Jane six-pack (or the Brit equivalent; football hooligans, mayhap?) into Oxford and Cambridge. There could be some short-term boost to the "outcomes" for those plebes in the labour market ("Ooh! Oxford!"), but in the medium to long-term it turns those former "elite" universities into just another community access college. This is a typical political decision, looking only as far as the next election and how to get votes from certain segments of the hoi-polloi. Demographics are Destiny, but a pig with lipstick is still a pig.
If you're poor and want to go to a fancy school, there are mechanisms for that known as "scholarships". This keeps the elite character of the school, in fact enhances it, as it brings in the best and brightest, not just the kids whose parents are wealthy and well-connected enough to get them in. Of course this is (gasp!) an argument for a meritocracy. The politically correct will not accept that as the basis for society, as it is too "exclusionary".
I want people smarter than me running certain things, certainly anything that involves a lot of math. Most people don't resent people more intelligent than themselves, (as long as their noses aren't rubbed in it) and can appreciate that not everybody can do everything equally well, or on some cases, at all. It's rather like arguments to keep the Olympics more open to less-than-elite athletes; I don't care to watch anyone competing in something that they aren't not in the very top rank of; consider women's hockey from the recent games. Most people can play hockey (for example) worse than pros, so they watch pros to see it at the highest (available) level.
"Equality" and "access" when combined should not (and literally don't) mean that everyone can do whatever they feel like whether or not they have the means (personal or material) to do so. The government is an institution designed to keep the lights on and the worst excesses of human nature under control. It has everywhere grown far beyond that, and although I like our medical system, I'm not fool enough to think that it comes for "free". The laws of Thermodynamics dictate that you don't get something for nothing, and it applies in the practical "real world" as well. Of course governments exist to control the population; as an exception, the U.S. Constitution took a stab at keeping government small and out of most of peoples' lives 200+ years ago, but now they have "No Child Left Behind", which (thank you, Law of Unintended
Consequences) is more like "No Child Gets Ahead". Cue Harrison Bergeron.
This is the real risk to our societies, not poor people having more kids than rich people. Poor kids can still be smart, and with WELL CONSIDERED incentives they can and should get ahead. Anything that doesn't involve taking an opportunity from someone else who would otherwise have it is fair game in my books.
Entitlement is a cancer eating away at Western civilization, but we'll see more attempts to impose it on the taxpayers until our system collapses. That is, assuming it hasn't already in some places; Greece is pretty much paralyzed with strikes and protests, and the Euro zone is in real trouble. One thing I can tell you with certainty is that Brussels won't be able to do more than paper over this, if it can do even that. More regulation will be their answer to this, not "live within your means".
As soon as people think that others will bail them out, they are no longer interested in being prudent. At a personal level that's welfare, or being handed a university placement that you didn't earn by brains or bank account. Back on the education angle, 50% of the population is BY DEFINITION below Average. No government initiative will change that; in fact no power on Earth can, and any ideas to the contrary are at best delusional. The US Army's ads from a few years back had it right: Be All That You Can Be. I don't live in "happy-self-esteem world" and out here everyone has limited potential, like it or not. You can push that potential to see how far you can go, but you can't be pulled there.
Sunday, 21 February 2010
Bogged down in Stanleygrad.
Islamabad, Pakistan (CNN) -- Another senior Afghan Taliban leader has been arrested in Pakistan, two Pakistani intelligence officials told CNN on Monday. "This arrest underscores a change in Pakistan's policy," Gul said. "This suggests their level of cooperation with the U.S. is much better than in the past." This is a key flaw in American in particular and Western foreign policy in general. When you talk smack about people that you would like to do your dirty work, it's hardly likely to make them willing to put themselves out on your behalf. "The enemy of my enemy is my friend" is a cornerstone of Realpolitik (even if not worded quite that bluntly) and there are times to shut up. More times in my opinion than there are to gob off about how other countries are handling their internal problems.
Now, the Bad:
The Afghan cabinet has revised the death toll from a NATO airstrike in the centre of the country down to 27 civilians killed, from 33 previously.
On Saturday, Afghan President Hamid Karzai admonished NATO troops for not doing enough to protect civilian lives. During a speech at the opening session of the Afghan parliament, Karzai called for extra caution on the part of NATO, which is currently conducting a massive offensive on the southern Taliban stronghold of Marjah in neighbouring Helmand province.
And last but far from least, the Ugly (from the main link):
MARJAH, Afghanistan — Outnumbered and outgunned, Taliban fighters are mounting a tougher fight than expected in Marjah, Afghan officials said Sunday, as U.S.-led forces converged on a pocket of militants in a western section of the town.
U.S. officials signalled their intention to attack Marjah, a major Taliban supply and opium-smuggling centre, months ago, apparently in hopes the insurgents would flee and allow the U.S.-led force to take over quickly and restore an Afghan government presence.
Instead, the insurgents rigged Marjah with bombs and booby traps to slow the allied attack, which began Feb. 13. Teams of Taliban gunmen stayed in the town, delivering sometimes intense volleys of gunfire on Marine and Afghan units slogging through the rutted streets and poppy fields.
Afghan Defence Ministry spokesman Gen. Mohammad Zahir Azimi said the U.S. and its allies had expected the Taliban to leave behind thousands of hidden explosives, which they did. But they were surprised to find that so many militants stayed to fight.
"Surprised", eh? Me, not so much. What the fuck did you THINK they would do if you gave them months (unmolested) to prepare? I know what I'd do in their place; each of my most zealous jihadis would be built multiple fortresses within the town with enough bombs, grenades, RPGs and small arms ammo to stage hit and run attacks every time the infidels turned a corner. Oh wait, that's they did too...I will say it here as unequivocally as I can: Gen. Stanley McCrystal's strategy for Afghanistan is stupid. Yes, stupid, rather like Hitler's decision to leave 6th Army in Stalingrad when the Soviets enveloped it, although the scale of the impending (military) disaster is of course smaller. If you wanted to do this, (it has been done in Fallujah) give the townies 24 hours notice to leave. That's enough time to sauve qui peut and let the Taliban small fry take off (the intent here) and NOT allow them months to mine and fortify the whole town.
Months of warning and they're still killing heaps (not really, but the media...) of civilians because they're being used as shields, and just because of standard war type stuff. Errant MLRS missiles wouldn't kill civvies who aren't there, and our side wouldn't be bogged down (in what I'll call Stanleygrad) if the good General's strategy had any firm basis in ground truth.
There are some signs of hope (see top) over there, but this is NOT one of them, and a public relations minefield to boot. Hopefully this debacle gets a new commander over there, but I'm not holding my breath waiting on that.
Saturday, 13 February 2010
Decline and Slide of the West
The big thing to take away from this is the concept of Material Productivity. There may be other terms, but it's exactly what I've been on about and it fits perfectly.
Yet Rome did not fall for four centuries after its moralists wrote of its decadence and decline. Why the resilience?
Entitlements and official corruption were for centuries subsidized by the profits accruing from global standardization and Romanization — brought about by the implementation and imposition of Roman law, order, and commerce throughout the Mediterranean. As long as the empire was cohesive, it brought in thousands yearly into its sphere of influence.
And:So such global uniformity created real wealth in newfound places faster than such bounty could corrupt the citizens in the old Italian core to the degree to bring down what was now a world system. In other words, the creation of entirely new cities like Leptis or the growth of Asian centers such as Ephesus, brought previously unproductive tribal folk into the Roman system at precisely the time old Romans were no longer doing the things that had once created their own vibrant culture that swept the Mediterranean — the ancient version of the Chinese youth working 10 hours in an Adidas factory while an American counterpart is still “finding himself.”
The point? We see something like this today. What made American culture boom through much of the nineteenth and twentieth centuries were traditional American values like the Protestant work ethic, family thrift, limited and stable government, equality of opportunity rather than result, lower taxes, personal freedom, opportunity for advancement and profit, and faith in American exceptionalism.
But the cloning and spreading of this system after WWII (“globalization”) did two things: literally billions of non-Westerners adopted the Western mode of production and began, in economic terms, becoming far more productive in creating valuable manufacturing goods, food, and exporting previously unknown or untapped natural resources; in addition, the vast rise in population added billions to the world’s productive work force.
Yes, lazily blockquoting someone else could be taken as another sign of said decline, but I do have a day job too. I am more than passingly familiar with the Roman Empire, though certainly no expert; this sounds like what happened to them, and the analogies with today are ignored at our peril.Something I know even less about is Economics, however the same could be said for most people who specialize in it; the Dismal Science indeed. Free Trade was seen by many as the thin edge of the predicament we find ourselves in, and can't claim mastery of the intricacies of those arguments. However, if there is one thing I have learned by surviving this long is that if you need a complicated explanation of or complex scheme for anything you're doing something wrong.
Brushing aside the obvious exceptions to that statement I am reminded of that one house that remained standing in Chicoutimi during the 1996 Saguenay flood while all else around it was washed away. The reason it stood is that it was built on bedrock. The more we undermine the foundations of our economy, the closer our collapse as a society comes. I think that NAFTA could have worked, as long as we protected it against wider competition. Even that is cold comfort to people who used to do jobs that moved to Mexico. Now those jobs have moved to China, and our wealth is moving in an ever widening loop, less of it making back to us.
Again, this is a more acute problem for the U.S. than for Canada, but I am not optimistic that all the recently lost manufacturing jobs will return to Ontario when this slump is over. Watch and shoot.
Wednesday, 10 February 2010
Engineering Twilight, Part Two
No, the plan was something that I've been thinking about for a while, and it has to do with our decreasing vision if not our absolute decline in ability to do certain things. I was watching something on the Military Channel about the SR-71 which had video of the production process. They had to make the plane out of titanium, so Lockheed developed techniques to cast and forge the stuff. The connection here is that while watching this I said "That represents the peak of American engineering".
It was a plane, and although it was really fast, it was no Three Gorges Dam or (more contemporaneous to it) Apollo Project, so I don't mean the most sophisticated or biggest thing built by man. What it meant to me, and I could be completely wrong, was that we have lost the sort of industrial "muscle" that would allow a single company to build something as outrageous as a plane that is 90% titanium and goes Mach 3.2+ at 85,000ft (or 3.5 at over 100,000ft, depending on your source).
Of course this would never have happened at any other time or place in history than in a still-prosperous U.S.A. in the throes of an ideological struggle for the political and economic soul of the world. The Cold War isn't seen like that any more, but that was what it was and Reagan finally won it by bankrupting the U.S.S.R. Since then the West has lacked that sort of far-horizon existential threat. The war against Islam is much older, but the threat is a lot less definable than that of the 1st Guards Tank Red Banner Army facing you over the IGB (Inner German Border).
The America that built the SR-71 is gone, and not looking likely to come back. I don't disagree with the decision to can the F-22, for example, but its' demise (or scaling back) is an early symptom of the U.S.A.'s own "Recessional":
Far-called, our navies melt away;
On dune and headland sinks the fire:
Lo, all our pomp of yesterday
Is one with Nineveh and Tyre!
Judge of the Nations, spare us yet,
Lest we forget - lest we forget!
There are a lot of things we can do today that couldn't be done 40-50 years ago, so we're not looking at a Dark Age just yet. A lot of the "fire" has gone out though, as current achievements are at a much smaller scale than in the 1950s and 60s. When you're working on
nanotech that's a good thing, but North America has dropped out of the race for a lot of things that we used to lead. Canada peaked in the 50s with the Avro Arrow, but our loss was the Yanks' gain as our people went to the Apollo program and elsewhere.
Science fiction has worked a great deal with the idea of a future when few people are needed to keep things running, and it is one possibility that the global population will peak and recede as everyone goes "post-industrial". The chickens of the cradle-to-grave Social Security state are beginning to roost as it becomes obvious to people other than Actuaries that we can't maintain the society we have designed for ourselves. That means different things to different people, but to me we need an economy which actually produces things as a foundation for its wealth, and we need it basically now.
Back to industry and engineering. As much as I don't hold with the (increasingly discredited and shrill) AGW models, we do need to wean ourselves off of oil. With good scrubbing technology we can keep using coal and certainly natural gas, but the key to all of these electric cars is, well electricity. "Clean" coal, hydro, natural gas and nuclear power plants will give us that, but to generate the added energy that recharging all of those batteries will require a lot more juice than we have available presently. Engineering advances remain to be made in all of these areas; simple, efficient nuke plants, efficient solar cells, and the holy grail of clean low-impact power generation, orbital solar power.
I'm a well-known cynic, but I know what we have done, so I know we could do that sort of thing again. The sort of drive and sense of purpose that built SR-71s could be turned loose on the engineering requirements of launching the solar platforms and building the receiving stations.
We are victims of our own success and the resultant lowered expectations. I have no idea where our tech will top out, but it shouldn't happen in my lifetime, and I want that cheap clean energy as much as the most ardent Green. You might be able to live as a "naked savage" on tropical beaches, but in this climate it takes energy just to survive 2/3 of the year. That's my pet hypothesis why Europe was first to develop advanced tech, though the Chinese had a head start and certainly could have come out ahead.
It starts in the homes and the schools of the nation. Kids should feel that they have a contribution to make, and the schools should identify strengths and guide those children to what they are proficient in. It wouldn't work for everyone, but there would be more plumbers, electricians, technicians, engineers, chemists, etc., and a lot fewer Art History majors. This is drifting into "Credentialism", another sign of our decline, but one which can be reined under control and even directed to the good of individuals and society.
Sustainable progress is the key to survival. Cheap clean energy is the key to wealth within that model, and keeping our R&D where it needs to be to get that requires us to put our industry back in business. Canada's not as far down the road of de-industrializing as the Americans are, but they have still far more industry than we've ever had, so we've not far to fall to hit our bottom.