There has been so much happening and all of it at a fair rate of change that
I have had a hard time coming up with a coherent idea for a post here, but I’ll
take a stab at it today.
Right now Da’esh is on the cusp of taking Kobani (spelling varies), a
Kurdish village on the border with Turkey. Turkey has voted to take military
action against Da’esh, bur are sitting on the border watching Da’esh overrun
the town while preventing Kurds on their side of the border from getting
through with reinforcements and resupply.
Turkey of course has a long violent history with the Kurds, but by their present actions they are ensuring that this continues. There are no simple solutions in that (and many other) part of the world, but if you want to move forward you have to change. Keeping the “enemy of my enemy is my friend” even under these circumstances is a sign of almost pathological hatred, and no good will come of it.
What I would do in Erdrogan’s place is push Da’esh out of a sizable chunk of
the area contiguous with Iraqi Kurdistan and encourage as many Kurds as
possible to move into it. This would give the Kurds what they want, rid Turkey
of its’ more restive Kurdish population (non-violently) and put a stick in
Assad’s spokes which Turkey is anxious to do. Looks win-win to me, certainly in
relation to what they’re doing now.
The last seismic shift in boundaries in the region was WW1, this is the next one. There is no more “Syria” nor for that matter really any “Iraq”. The resulting vacuum (from failed revolution in the former and failed nation-building in the latter) will be filled by something, as Da’esh is doing right now. The one place where nation-building has a chance (few sure-things in this life) is with a self-identifying group, and the Kurds are one such. This sort of chaos doesn't have to benefit only the bad apples, but force will be required and eggs will be cracked for any such omelette. Mixed food metaphors, but you get the idea. I don’t see a good outcome to this as the will to take the action required is lacking in those who have the power and resources to make it happen.
Speaking of political will, we also have Ebola to deal with. Liberia is on
the verge of total collapse, although with its’ recent history that was never
too far off at the best of times. These local tragedies would be of scant
concern for any other than humanitarian reasons were it not for a confluence of
two features of modern life: air travel and Political Correctness.
It is abundantly clear that this is a deadly disease with a c. 40% mortality
rate even if you get proper care, worse if you don’t. It’s no SARS in terms of
transmission, but in the later stages of incubation all body fluids are
vectors, and with fever, nausea and diarrhoea the main symptoms, there are many
opportunities if you aren’t quarantined.
This is precisely what needs to be done: quarantine the region. That will be
impossible to 100% enforce of course, but without an attempt it will spread
everywhere. It has shown up so far in the USA, Spain and now Macedonia, and
that’s just what I can remember with certainty right now. Screening measures
are going into place but are easily spoofed by people taking standard
anti-inflammatory meds or by people lying about their point of origin.
Some airlines have stopped going to these countries, but unless all of them
do it won’t stop it. This is frightening enough, but it gets worse. Think panicked mass migration. "Katie, bar the door" indeed, but you
won’t like what it would entail to do so. Positive enforcement of borders while
ensuring zero entry of desperate and possibly sick people cannot end well and
WOULD necessitate lethal force. The only thing which might dissuade someone
facing something like Ebola from going where they think they’ll get better
medical care is them knowing that they’ll be killed if they try it. What
(Western) politician is willing to make THAT call?
Yeah, we’re screwed, but no change there. I may be laying in more emergency
food supplies, but if I’m going to do so I’d best do it soon. Likely it won’t
come to that here, but even if not I’d best lay in some ammo in case these Da’esh
fanboys try to take a
crack at us in our “bedrooms”.
Turkey of course has a long violent history with the Kurds, but by their present actions they are ensuring that this continues. There are no simple solutions in that (and many other) part of the world, but if you want to move forward you have to change. Keeping the “enemy of my enemy is my friend” even under these circumstances is a sign of almost pathological hatred, and no good will come of it.
The last seismic shift in boundaries in the region was WW1, this is the next one. There is no more “Syria” nor for that matter really any “Iraq”. The resulting vacuum (from failed revolution in the former and failed nation-building in the latter) will be filled by something, as Da’esh is doing right now. The one place where nation-building has a chance (few sure-things in this life) is with a self-identifying group, and the Kurds are one such. This sort of chaos doesn't have to benefit only the bad apples, but force will be required and eggs will be cracked for any such omelette. Mixed food metaphors, but you get the idea. I don’t see a good outcome to this as the will to take the action required is lacking in those who have the power and resources to make it happen.
No comments:
Post a Comment